What Is The Difference Between 2nd-gen Vs 3rd-gen Echo Dot? [New 2020]

2nd-gen Vs 3rd-gen Echo Dot

If you are considering Between 2nd-gen Vs 3rd-gen Echo Dot, Colorfy provides you some information about these two types of speakers to help you determine better.

Amazon’s Alexa-powered third-gen Echo Dot was out for a while now. Provided that in reality, that a lot of us are probably scratching our heads in an effort to recall what the previous generation looked or sounded like.

The first Dot helped revolutionize the wise house by producing virtual assistants more approachable (and cheap ), ushering in the age of this voice-controlled smart house. The brand new third-generation Echo Dot sport a lot of the very same features as its predecessors, however having a couple of much-needed improvements.

The most recent iteration is stronger than previous versions and keeps its own line-out and Bluetooth connectivity to both bodily and wireless links. Alexa has also obtained a respectable overhaul, and she possesses a lot of brand new features and techniques.

Echo Dot (3rd Gen)

Echo Dot (3rd Gen)

Whether you already possess 2nd Gen Echo Dot or are seeking to purchase in the Alexa ecosystem for the first time, then the Echo Dot (3rd Gen) is an outstanding product. It looks fantastic, sounds better than ever, and keeps the superb price tag.


  • Vastly improved speakers
  • Gorgeous fabric layout
  • Still really Inexpensive
  • New Plum color!


  • No actual difference in performance compared to 2nd Gen Dot

Echo Dot (2nd Gen)

Echo Dot (2nd Gen)

The Echo Dot (2nd Gen) still functions just fine in 2019, but if you’ve got the capacity to update, the Echo Dot (3rd Gen) provides a far better all-around encounter. Because Amazon no longer sells this device, in the event that you needed to pick up the one you will have to hit the reseller market.


  • Connects to additional speakers
  • Same great Alexa encounter


  • Sound quality does not hold up
  • The plastic layout is dull
  • No longer available for sale on Amazon

Already have an Echo Dot (2nd Gen)? The brand new 3rd Gen version functions the same but provides considerably better audio quality and a layout that is an improvement in every way you look at it. This is not an essential update, but it is one we believe you’re going to be glad to make if you are due.

2nd-gen Vs 3rd-gen Echo Dot: In-Depth Comparison


The layout is where the largest difference between both smart speakers are available. Echo Dot 2 includes a contemporary design with borders and bold colors that stand out. About the design 3, this has been changed into a more contemporary minimalist design with curved edges and is coated with cloth Which Makes the apparatus blends well with its surroundings

The quantity, microphone, and activity buttons are located on the very top of both speakers. The Echo Dot2 is produced from a plastic exterior which we believe looks better than the milder design covered in cloth on the Echo Dot3.

The color options are extremely different for both apparatus. Echo Dot2 just has White and Black colors to select from, which can be really nice, since they stand out and seem futuristic. The Echo Dot3, on the other hand, has Charcoal, Heather Gray, and Sandstone. Nearly 1/3 of this unit is covered in cloth and it uses quite conservative colors that let it blend nicely with the environment.

In terms of the dimensions and weight, Echo Dot2 is smaller using a dimension of 32mm in height and 83.5millimeters in diameter. The Echo Dot 3 includes a dimension of 43mm in height and 99mm in diameter. Dot 2 can also be lighter, nearly by half, weighing just 163 g, whilst Dot3 weights 300 g.

Nevertheless, this can not be considered an advantage for your Echo Dot2, since from the wise speaker business, nobody actually cares about the weight and size. Consumers aren’t supposed to carry around these devices, so greater features in the market for Quicker layout is a trade-off a lot of people would not mind.

The same as in any market, the layout will likely be based on personal taste. So we’ll provide Echo Dot 2 a benefit for getting a contemporary vibe to it. The way it had been designed makes it resemble a super expensive hockey puck rather than this “mainstream” style of this Dot3.

Performance Comparison

Unlike smartphones in which the operation is quantified by the hardware and its operating system, smart speakers largely rely on its own applications and AI abilities to produce a seamless interaction with the consumer. The response speed of the voice helper and precision of speech recognition ought to be confirmed and improved at a fast speed to maintain the apparatus aggressively.

The distinction between smart speakers and smartphones is that there’ll always be just 1 voice helper across different speakers in precisely the exact same business. Smartphones get obsolete due to many things, including the gap in the hardware and operating system variants. So rather than comparing apparatus with their own hardware, there are various performance checks which have been conducted to validate the truth of those speakers.

There are 4 functionality checks that smart speakers will need to maneuver and always improve to produce their apparatus more interactive and effective at ridding a wise home. Before we proceed using the results of the tests conducted by Allion Labs, It’s Far Better to know the parameters Which Were used for the evaluations, which comprises:

  • FRR (False Rejection Rate) – that is actually the test that was performed to learn how lots of the aftermath term was rejected or wasn’t recognized by Alexa.
  • RAR (Response precision Rate) – this test assesses the accuracy speed of conversing together with Amazon’s smart speakers and providing the proper information which has been required to be shown through the dialogue. The higher it’s, the more reliable the info a wise speaker will provide.
  • WWDD (Wake Word Planner Delay) – a good, smart speaker ought to be able to react instantaneously with the aftermath term and provide the outcomes that were being requested. The slower a system responds, the reduced it ranks from the evaluation outcome.
  • FAR (False Alarm Rate) – that is conducted to understand how often these wise speakers have been triggered without intentionally utilizing the aftermath word. When using a lengthy conversation with somebody, it’s not tough to utilize the aftermath word or comparable audio that may trigger the speaker to do tasks.

The departure rate for WWDD is significantly less than 1 minute, and Amazon’s Alexa handed it by listing 0.1-second WWDD, which is now the quickest among speakers that are smart. Alexa also passed the FFR with just the playback device group falling somewhat short by just 4 percent. RAR is where Alexa endures the most, out of all of the categories, it just passed the apparatus playback and listed 2% over the passing speed. Alexa also passed the FAR and has been just incrementally triggered 2 days following 24 hours of testing.

In case you noticed, the majority of the classes where Alexa has passed just required the aftermath word and there’s still some work that should be achieved for its speech recognition. There’s not anything wrong with it, since said, smart speakers are still at the very early phases of advancement and unlike applications that need constant updates to acquire voice supporters get better as an increasing number of individuals interact with this.

Performance-wise, there’s absolutely no winner involving Echo Dot 2 and Dot 3. These devices will likely always be smart and aren’t prone to being lethargic with time. These devices utilize the exact same applications and voice helper, therefore it’s an even match with this particular aspect.


That is the single most significant gap between the two devices since the next generation seems considerably better than the next generation.

The brand new 3rd-gen Echo Dot includes one 1.6-inch speaker sending out 360-degree audio. The second-generation Dot had a single smaller speaker (1.1 inches ) ) that leaked audio from numerous jackholes. Since the driver is considerably bigger on the third-generation Echo Dot, this assists the puck-like apparatus to deliver stronger sound with lower distortion. Amazon asserts the third-gen Dot is 70% louder than its second-gen counterpart. Actually, our tester gave the apparatus an Editors’ Choice award for those improvements Amazon created in the audio section.

The newest device sports a brand new mike arrangement. Instead of the seven-microphone range found on earlier productions of the Echo and Echo Dot, the most recent Dot only uses four far-field mics to listen to you from throughout the room. Our reviewers discovered the brand new Echo Dot could hear the aftermath word from throughout the area with music that was loud.

The Dot still keeps the 3.5-millimeter interface for linking to an outside speaker. You may even link it to an outside speaker through Bluetooth. As a consequence, it is easy to add your own stronger speakers for your setup without needing to purchase the bigger, more competent Echo. Since Amazon came out with all the Echo Sub, a potent subwoofer that is intended to match with your already-existing apparatus, it’s possible to definitely turn the bass up.

Alexa voice helper

The Alexa voice helper technology is precisely the exact same in both the next – and – third-generation Echo Dots. Upgrades to Alexa capacities like voice fitting and smart house connectivity have been issued via firmware upgrades that don’t have anything to do with all the speakers where the voice comes out. Thus, if you are trying to determine how they fit up, the voice technologies probably should not factor into your choice.


This is the part that levels the playing field for both the Dot 2 and Dot 3. Both these devices comprise a 3.5millimeter audio jack, Bluetooth, and Wi-Fi connection. There is nothing exciting about the 3.5millimeter audio jack and Wi-Fi link. The Bluetooth capability, on the other hand, is where things become interesting.

As you have seen from all of the segments that we’ve examined, there are just two distinct differences between both smart speakers; layout and sound quality. The layout is based on personal taste. For the sound quality, but in case you’ve got a spare wireless speaker, then it is possible to join the two of these devices to get better audio quality.

Even though the 3rd-generation Echo Dot boasts with louder and better sound, it is still far from attaining the standard of speakers. That’s why if you’ve got a spare wireless speaker in-home, Echo Dot two will do the job just fine and it saves you the trouble of updating to some other device.


As Echo speakers proceed, neither of them is especially pricey. The 3rd-Gen model begins at $49.99, the 2nd-Gen version at $39.99. But, the two devices are usually discounted; in the wake of Cyber Monday, Amazon was selling the 2nd Gen for $24.99, together with the 3rd Gen heading for $29.99. We expect to keep to see significant reductions on the 2nd-Gen Dot, as is often the situation when Amazon Attempts to clean out old versions

If saving money is a priority for you, this is a wonderful time to obtain the discounted 2nd-Gen Echo Dot. But given the huge gap in quality between both of these speakers, we anticipate a price drop of $10 (and much less if the apparatus are discounted) will not matter for many shoppers.

Both devices also occasionally come bundled with other products, which means you need to keep a lookout for all those bargains. As an instance, you can now get the 2nd-Generation Dot bundled together with all the Fire TV Stick at a discount. You can also save $30 on the 3rd-Generation Dot bundled together with all the Amazon Smart Plug.

See also: Best Alexa devices for 2020: From smart speakers to video doorbells

Should you upgrade?

It is hard to urge that you simply throw out a perfectly good functioning product, simply because something newer and better has come along. On the other hand, the Echo Dot (3rd Gen) is indeed far better than the second-generation Dot which we can not argue with you in the event that you choose to proceed.

The fabric design is much more stylish, the speaker is much better, and also the multiple color choices (such as a fairly new Plum color) make this an effortless upgrade option for us. Just take those old Echo Dots and transfer to a guest room, office, or garage, and include the Echo Dot (3rd Gen) prominently and proudly from the busiest rooms at your home!

Video: How to set up the Amazon Echo Dot with Clock

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *